Client who sued Hagens Berman over failed Thalidomide case settles

by | Sep 25, 2020

From the PENNSYLVANIA RECORD, Thursday, September 24, 2020

PHILADELPHIA – With the case set to press on after a harsh ruling from the judge hearing it, the law firm Hagens Berman has reached a settlement with a disgruntled former client.

On Sept. 17, Carolyn Sampson and Hagens Berman reported a confidential settlement between the two. It followed Judge Paul Diamond’s rejection of a stay request from the firm as it fights claims over failed Thalidomide litigation.

“The sky has not fallen,” wrote U.S. District Judge Paul S. Diamond over the prominent Seattle law firm’s argument it needs more time to fight his order rejecting a transfer of the lawsuit to Texas. “Hagens Berman has not alleged any harm beyond the mere fact that the litigation will continue in this Court while the Firm petitions for mandamus.”

This is the second time Hagens Berman has tried to halt actions by Judge Diamond in litigation swirling around its ill-fated decision to represent people who claimed they were injured by Thalidomide. The drug was briefly on the market in the early 1960s until it was linked to severe birth defects in children whose mothers took it to prevent morning sickness.

The lawsuits collapsed after defendants obtained information showing the plaintiffs knew or should have known decades earlier that the drug was the cause of their deformities.

Judge Diamond ordered the firm to pay $145,000 in sanctions in 2015 over its behavior, which the law firm is still fighting. Hagens Berman ultimately dismissed many of the suits against lead defendant GlaxoSmithKline in what a special master described as a “suspicious” arrangement under which Glaxo also dropped its request for sanctions.

Then in a further development, the law firm informed the court one of its lawyers had falsified a medical expert’s report to convince a client to drop her claims.

The revelations led Sampson to sue the law firm earlier this year, accusing it of putting “the protection of its own financial, publicity, and reputational interests before those of the clients they recruited into a lawsuit without a fair disclosure of their chances of success.”

She didn’t formally allege legal malpractice, instead accusing the law firm of conspiracy and inflicting emotional and financial distress upon her.

John Marshall

Most of us participated in a guided tour of the US Capitol Building. Most impressive, in my opinion, was the Rotunda, the infamous domed circular room in the center of the Capitol. The historical paintings i.e., the Declaration of Independence along with the statues and busts of former presidents were impressive. BUT no one could resist looking up!

The conference was a jam-packed three days ending with a “roaming” dinner in the hotel. The term is used lightly, as it turns out, we have a party animal in our midst. Our fearless leader, JoJo Calora, had quite the set-up in his room. He had karaoke goin’ on. He also cranked up the tunes and blasted out heavy metal! Did you know there’s a song about thalidomide? It’s called “Prescribing Horror” by Exodus. You shouldn’t listen to it before you go to sleep. LOL! Fortunately, no neighbors complained, and fun was had by all. Although there was food, snacks, and drinks in three other rooms, people didn’t roam much. JoJo had the fun room! Can’t wait for next year!

Robert Gamble, JoJo and Elizabeth


We consider this conference successful! We are moving forward with our campaign and we can’t do it alone. We need YOUR help! Write your senators and representatives! Tell your friends what we have learned. One person could be the link we need to be heard. Be a part of our success story!

Need assistance with this process? Please call our info line (612-440-1920) and we’ll connect you with our legislative committee!